The Validity of Re-introduction
Another reason for caution
over reintroductions of carnivores, and other locally extirpated species, to
Britain is that, although we assume humans are responsible for their
demise, at present we are not certain that this was the case.
In truth, astonishingly
little is known about the timing and circumstances of many extirpations.
Without evidence for the ancient history of these species, cases for re-wilding
largely collapse because the IUCN requirements for reintroduction, which state
that the factors responsible for a species’ extinction must be identified
before a reintroduction can be considered cannot be met.
This is where studies of
species history and archaeology are likely to become vital for informing future
management of biodiversity.
However, the final
question that we must address is ‘why’? What are we trying to achieve? Is
re-wilding about conservation, guilt or profit-making, after all endangered is
often a good money-spinner. The answers
are not always clear but history does have lessons to teach.